• About Us
  • Our Services
    • Banking & Financial Services
    • Competition & Antitrust
    • Digital & Tech
    • EU & International
    • Food & Drink
    • Green Transition, Energy & Industrials
    • Healthcare, Life Sciences & Wellbeing
    • Trade & Investment (including EU-UK)
    • Transport, Travel & Logistics
  • Our Team
    • FIPRA International
    • Special Advisors
  • FIPRA Network
  • Latest News
  • Careers
Skip to content

FIPRA

COVID-19 Resources
Search for:
Analysis

Why Italy’s institutional crisis plays into the hands of the populists

Wednesday, 30 May 2018
Why Italy’s institutional crisis plays into the hands of the populists

How Italy has been plunged into an institutional crisis

83 turbulent days of political negotiations did not suffice in giving Italy its first-ever Eurosceptic Government, as the President of the Republic, Sergio Mattarella, rejected the take-it-or-leave-it nomination of professor Paolo Savona as the Economy Ministry. The halt forced prime minister designate Giuseppe Conte to step down, triggering an institutional crisis whose consequences are still in the making.

Yet the President’s decision – however politically impactful – is legitimate and well grounded. The Italian Constitution states that the President of the Republic “appoints the President of the Council of Ministers and, on his proposal, the Ministers”, and the President’s decision falls precisely within this remit.

But beyond the constitutional grounds, two points of Mattarella’s argument deserve a mention. Mattarella noted that the appointment of the economy ministry “delivers an immediate message – which can be either of trust or alarm – to the financial world”. Political uncertainty, he added, casted serious doubts over Italy’s fiscal solvency – whose consequences already materialised in a 200-billion loss in the stock market over the last 3 weeks, coupled with a raise of Italy’s interest rates on 10-year bonds up to 2,7%.

Mattarella then insisted that any attempt to exit the Eurozone would threat Italians’ savings – which the Constitution does safeguard – before arguing that “If we want to discuss it [Italy’s membership of the Eurozone], we have to do it openly, as it hasn’t been a salient topic of the latest elections.” In other words, if a new potential 5Star-League-led government is serious about questioning the Euro, both parties need to give up on their ambiguity on the issue, which they arguably benefited from during the electoral campaign ahead of the March elections. While this ambiguity was read by many in Italy as an attempt from both parties to drop their call for a referendum on the Euro – attempting to appeal to voters towards the centre of the political spectrum – the nomination of Paolo Savona, an economist who theorised pulling Italy out of the Euro by stealth in 2015, inevitably rekindled the fear.

Both the 5star Movement’s leader Luigi di Maio and League’s Matteo Salvini lashed out at the President’s decision, with the former going as far as to call for the impeachment of the President – something which the Italian constitution allows only “for high treason or attacks against the constitution”.

However, the fact that both 5Star Movement and League proposed a Eurosceptic like Savona as the only available option, while conscious of the President’s firm stance – and full power to reject his name – may suggests that an actual compromise was not their ultimate interests. Reading this hazardous move through the lenses of the latest polls – which picture a rising centre-right coalition – could help explain League’s appetite for new elections in the short term.

Why uncertainty is there to stay

As the chance for a populist government to take shape fell apart, President Mattarella gave a new mandate to the economist Carlo Cottarelli, a former Director at the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and Commissioner for Spending Review (a government-appointed official in charge of cutting spending in the public sector).

While Cottarelli’s profile can reassure financial markets as well as European partners about Italy’s financial spending and economic policy, it is hard to see how he can win a confidence vote in both houses of the Parliament, where 5Star Movement and League hold a majority. 

Should Cottarelli succeed in securing a confidence vote, his government’s main task would be to manage a loss of market confidence, clearing a Financial bill before the end of the year and heading towards new elections in early 2019. More realistically, should the government fail in gathering MPs’ backing, elections could be convened as early as July.

This institutional crisis, as fluid as it remains now, leaves substantial questions open. Will the next elections be held under the same electoral law (a mixed system which combines a first past the post with a proportional method) which is likely once again to give birth to a hung-parliament? Will the 5Star Movement and the League run as formal allies? Will their ambiguity over the Euro – which persists at the moment – reward them again at the next elections, or will it rather backfire? Will we experience a revival of the centre-right alliance between the League and Berlusconi’s Forza Italia?

Beyond that, how the electoral campaign will be framed will be crucial. Should Italians find themselves entrenched in a debate over Italy’s permanence on the Eurozone, or should rather it take the form of an irreducible clash between technocracy/Europe vs democracy/national interest, then Conte’s failed experiment will play into the hands of populists’ rhetoric. Ironically, what halted populists from embarking in a radical confrontation with the EU may give them another electoral boost.

This piece was written by Matteo Vittori, Fipra International. Fipra also has a well-established Unit in Italy which can provide support with Government Relations as well as deeper analysis into political situations should your business need it. For more information please contact Fipra Italy

Latest News
  • FIPRA Network
    Dutch cabinet resigns: First overview from The Hague
    15 January 2021
  • FIPRA Network
    View from the United States: From impeachment to political reconciliation
    13 January 2021
  • Analysis
    A new era: Examining the EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement
    6 January 2021
  • FIPRA Network
    First look: China-EU Comprehensive Agreement of Investment spurs optimism
    6 January 2021
  • Events
    Recovery, regulation & global ties: Portugal’s leitmotiv for Council Presidency
    15 December 2020
  • FIPRA in Argentina
    FIPRA in Argentina
    is known locally as InfoMedia Consulting
    FIPRA in Argentina
  • FIPRA in Australia
    FIPRA in Australia
    is known locally as Richardson Coutts
    FIPRA in Australia
  • FIPRA in Austria
    FIPRA in Austria
    is known locally as PANTARHEI Corporate Advisors
    FIPRA in Austria
  • FIPRA in Belgium
    FIPRA in Belgium
    is known locally as Politics Matters
    FIPRA in Belgium
  • FIPRA in Brazil
    FIPRA in Brazil
    is known locally as JG Assis de Almeida & Associados
    FIPRA in Brazil
  • FIPRA in Canada
    FIPRA in Canada
    is known locally as Earnscliffe Strategy Group
    FIPRA in Canada
  • FIPRA in China
    FIPRA in China
    is known locally as Yuan Associates
    FIPRA in China
  • FIPRA in Croatia
    FIPRA in Croatia
    is known locally as Vlahovic Group
    FIPRA in Croatia
  • FIPRA in Czech Republic
    FIPRA in Czech Republic
    is known locally as PAN Solutions
    FIPRA in Czech Republic
  • FIPRA in Denmark
    FIPRA in Denmark
    is known locally as European Advisers
  • FIPRA in Estonia
    FIPRA in Estonia
    is known locally as META Advisory Group
    FIPRA in Estonia
  • FIPRA in France
    FIPRA in France
    is known locally as Cabinet Samman
    FIPRA in France
  • FIPRA in Georgia
    FIPRA in Georgia
    is known locally as BGI Advisory Services Group
    FIPRA in Georgia
  • FIPRA in Germany
    FIPRA in Germany
    is known locally as Miller & Meier Consulting
    FIPRA in Germany
  • FIPRA in Greece
    FIPRA in Greece
    is known locally as One Team S.A
    FIPRA in Greece
  • FIPRA in Hungary
    FIPRA in Hungary
    is known locally as CEC Government Relations Budapest
    FIPRA in Hungary
  • FIPRA in India
    FIPRA in India
    is known locally as Chase India
    FIPRA in India
  • FIPRA in Ireland
    FIPRA in Ireland
    is known locally as Vulcan Consulting
    FIPRA in Ireland
  • FIPRA in Italy
    FIPRA in Italy
    is known locally as Telos A&S
    FIPRA in Italy
  • FIPRA in Japan
    FIPRA in Japan
    is known locally as GR Japan
    FIPRA in Japan
  • FIPRA in Kazakhstan
    FIPRA in Kazakhstan
    is known locally as Kesarev
    FIPRA in Kazakhstan
  • FIPRA in Korea
    FIPRA in Korea
    is known locally as Macoll Consulting Group
    FIPRA in Korea
  • FIPRA in Kyrgyzstan
    FIPRA in Kyrgyzstan
    is known locally as Kesarev
    FIPRA in Kyrgyzstan
  • FIPRA in Latvia
    FIPRA in Latvia
    is known locally as Meta Advisory
    FIPRA in Latvia
  • FIPRA in Luxembourg
    FIPRA in Luxembourg
    is known locally as Huggard Consulting Group
    FIPRA in Luxembourg
  • FIPRA in Malta
    FIPRA in Malta
    is known locally as Maritimus Company Limited
    FIPRA in Malta
  • FIPRA in Mexico
    FIPRA in Mexico
    is known locally as InStrag
    FIPRA in Mexico
  • FIPRA in Mongolia
    FIPRA in Mongolia
    is known locally as Kesarev
    FIPRA in Mongolia
  • FIPRA in The Netherlands
    FIPRA in The Netherlands
    is known locally as Public Matters
    FIPRA in The Netherlands
  • FIPRA in Norway
    FIPRA in Norway
    is known locally as First House
    FIPRA in Norway
  • FIPRA in Poland
    FIPRA in Poland
    is known locally as CEC Government Relations
    FIPRA in Poland
  • FIPRA in Portugal
    FIPRA in Portugal
    is known locally as Initium
  • FIPRA in Russia
    FIPRA in Russia
    is known locally as Kesarev
    FIPRA in Russia
  • FIPRA in Singapore
    FIPRA in Singapore
    is known locally as Landmark Public Affairs
    FIPRA in Singapore
  • FIPRA in Slovenia
    FIPRA in Slovenia
    is known locally as MC Public Affairs Ltd
    FIPRA in Slovenia
  • FIPRA in South Africa
    FIPRA in South Africa
    is known locally as Ethicore Political Consulting
    FIPRA in South Africa
  • FIPRA in Spain
    FIPRA in Spain
    is known locally as Influence Spain
    FIPRA in Spain
  • FIPRA in Sweden
    FIPRA in Sweden
    is known locally as Hallvarsson & Halvarsson (H&H)
    FIPRA in Sweden
  • FIPRA in Switzerland
    FIPRA in Switzerland
    is known locally as Hirzel.Neef.Schmid. Consultants
    FIPRA in Switzerland
  • FIPRA in Tajikistan
    FIPRA in Tajikistan
    is known locally as Kesarev
    FIPRA in Tajikistan
  • FIPRA in Turkey
    FIPRA in Turkey
    is known locally as FIPRA Iletisim
  • FIPRA in Turkmenistan
    FIPRA in Turkmenistan
    is known locally as Kesarev
    FIPRA in Turkmenistan
  • FIPRA in Ukraine
    FIPRA in Ukraine
    is known locally as Stober Poltavets & Associates
    FIPRA in Ukraine
  • FIPRA in the United Kingdom
    FIPRA in the United Kingdom
    is known locally as Lexington Communications
    FIPRA in the United Kingdom
  • FIPRA in the United States
    FIPRA in the United States
    is known locally as Alpine Group
    FIPRA in the United States
  • FIPRA in Uzbekistan
    FIPRA in Uzbekistan
    is known locally as Kesarev
    FIPRA in Uzbekistan
FIPRA Network

FIPRA

© FIPRA 2021.
All rights reserved.

Follow us on Twitter  Find us on LinkedIn

  • Privacy Policy
Explore
  • About Us
  • Our Services
  • Our Team
  • FIPRA Network
  • Latest News
  • FIPRA Tools
  • Contact Us
Services
  • Banking & Financial Services
  • Competition & Antitrust
  • Digital & Tech
  • EU & International
  • Food & Drink
  • Green Transition, Energy & Industrials
  • Healthcare, Life Sciences & Wellbeing
  • Trade & Investment (including EU-UK)
  • Transport, Travel & Logistics
Contact

info@fipra.com

Brussels Office  map
Rue de la Loi 227
Brussels 1040
+32 (0)2 613 28 28

London Office  map
201 Borough High Street
London
SE1 1JA
+44 (0)203 805 7770

Company no: 3936157

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. To get more info on our use of cookies please see our privacy policy.AcceptRejectPrivacy policy
You can revoke your consent any time using the Revoke consent button.Revoke cookies